• About
  • Disclaimer
  • Links
  • Market Wisdom
  • Practical Wisdom
  • Video/Audio Market Wisdom
  • Video/Audio Practical Wisdom

Zone of Competence

~ Dollars, Sense, and Probabilities.

Zone of Competence

Tag Archives: Investing

Welcome to October. Trick or Treat?

10 Friday Oct 2014

Posted by JC in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Investing

We are finally getting some overdue weakness in the stock market. I say overdue, because we haven’t had a 10% correction since 2011.

Still, the S&P 500 at yesterday’s close of 1928.21 is only down 4.5% from its 52-week high of 2019.26. While no one knows what the future holds, some context can be helpful when pondering what may be in store for your portfolio.

Where We Stand

The bull market is five and a half years old and the S&P 500 has roughly tripled over that time. Some say it has all been due to the Fed, but earnings have also been on a tear since the bottom in March of 2009.

I don’t see signs of a recession on the near-term horizon for the economy. This would suggest that downside should be limited. That said, we can easily expect a 10-12% correction sometime soon (this may be it).

And with the age of the bull market, international economic weakness, the strong dollar, and the end of quantitative easing, a 20-30% cyclical bear market can’t be ruled out. But a 50% wipeout, while not being beyond the realm of possibility, would seem to be quite unlikely.

Jeff Saut, the chief strategist for Raymond James, sees a correction soon, but thinks we are in a secular (long-term) bull market like 1982-2000. If so, selloffs are long-term buying opportunities.

Take The Long View

If you are invested in equities, you have to take the long view. Have a good plan and an asset allocation that is appropriate for your goals and risk tolerance, but know that the price of good long-term returns in stocks is occasional near-term unpleasantness.

Unless the fundamentals of the businesses you are invested in have deteriorated, there is no reason to sell, and good reason to consider buying on price weakness.

“Real investment risk is measured not by the percent that a stock may decline in price in relation to the general market in a given period, but by the danger of a loss of quality and earnings power through economic changes or deterioration in management.” — Benjamin Graham

Retirees Need A Portfolio That Will Allow Them To Sleep At Night

If you are fully invested and a retiree or near-retiree, the prospect of a selloff is not very pleasant. Asset allocation and risk management are key. You need to create a portfolio you can live with in good times and bad without panic selling at the bottom.

“Ultimately, nothing should be more important to investors than the ability to sleep soundly at night.” — Seth Klarman

For Young People, A Selloff Is Good News

Jason Zweig quipped that he’d like to start the Benjamin Graham Financial Network, which would report selloffs as good news.

Particularly if you are a young person just starting out, downward volatility is your friend because you can buy cheap, and you will be shoveling money in and compounding your returns for decades to come.

Your emotions may suggest differently, but a selloff is good news for you as long as you have the fortitude to keep buying when stocks are going down. Remember that money you will need or want in the next 5 years has no business being in the stock market.

“If you are shopping for common stocks, choose them the way you would buy groceries, not the way you would buy perfume.” — Benjamin Graham

Emotion Is The Investor’s Biggest Enemy

Emotion is the investor’s chief enemy, because it makes us want to buy after stocks have gone up, and sell during and after a selloff. Leaning against your emotions is one of the most important parts of being a successful investor.

If you can’t do it yourself, a good adviser can be worth their weight in gold if they can talk you down off of the ledge and keep you from selling into a panic.

The time to prepare for a selloff is when the market is charging higher. The emotions are too punishing to think rationally to come up with a plan during a selloff.

“The real ‘perfect’ portfolio is whatever approach allows you to stick with your investment plan without completely abandoning your strategy at the worst possible times.” — Ben Carlson

Season of the Witch

October has a reputation as the month of crashes, and several famous ones have come during the month — 1929, 1987, 2008. However, it has better average performance than September, though this doesn’t help much if this year is one of the outliers.

But October is also the end of the traditionally weak 6 months beginning in May, and many times it is when a near-term bottom is made. And the upcoming 3rd year of the Presidential Cycle is also usually quite strong.

The Long Term Looks Bright

None of these positive seasonal tendencies are guarantees, but doom and gloom predictions should be ignored.

The advances ahead in technology in general, and biotechnology in particular, will likely be amazing. And as Jeff Saut has pointed out, the American Energy Revolution is like putting Saudi Arabia on top of America’s industrial might. These factors all seem very bullish long term.

Never lose faith in the ingenuity of the American people. This is what you are betting on in the stock market in the long term.

Keep one eye on valuation and another on risk management, and you will be fine. Make a good plan and stick with it through thick and thin.

See also:

Current Thoughts

Charlie Munger and The Miracle of Tax-Efficient Compounding

Barry Ritholtz Radio Interview with Jeff Saut

Judith Curry: Climate Scientist Sees Global Warming Statistical Meltdown

Buzzkill for Stoners

Harvest Time?

27 Saturday Sep 2014

Posted by JC in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Ethanol, Farming, Farmland, Investing

I am not a farmer, but I live in Iowa so it is impossible not to care about agriculture as it is the driver of the local economy. I preface my comments by saying I know little to nothing about the business of farming. As an Iowan, I certainly hope we never have to live through another period like the Farm Depression of the 1980’s. It appears that farmers have learned their lesson according to statistics I have seen that have them taking on much less debt than the boom years before that crash. To that, I say, “Thank God.”

That said, there’s an interesting article in Barron’s titled “Harvest Time for Farming Shares.”

As anyone who has paid any attention at all knows, after an amazing multi-year run of prosperity, farming is undergoing tougher times with the prices of ag commodities down substantially in the last few years. For example, after topping out around $8.00 a bushel in 2012, the corn futures price has recently plumbed new lows in the $3.20’s. As the article states, this has potential implications for Deere (DE), Potash (POT), and Monsanto (MON). Here is the corn futures chart from Finviz.

fut_chart.ashx

Ethanol Demand Growth Fizzles

One of the main drivers of the corn boom of the last decade has been the increasing ethanol mandates. But, with refiners bumping up against the 10% blend wall, it is hard to see a lot of upside in demand from here.

This Fall’s expected bumper crops have driven down the price of corn, but who knows what next year’s weather holds. So the current price decline is likely overdone.

In the long term, expected growth of the world population should give farming a strong tailwind.

Extreme Valuations for West Central Indiana

Something that would give me pause is the following chart showing the historical farmland price to cash rent ratio. As Barron’s points out, current land prices look pretty rich by that measure.

Farmland Price to Cash Rent 092714

A report last month by Purdue’s Boehlje and his colleagues Timothy Baker and Michael Langemeier showed that central Indiana cropland has reached an average price that’s over 32 times the cash rent (as we show in the nearby chart), versus a 50-year average of 18 times. ‘Help us understand why you would pay today $32 for a dollar of earnings from farmland,’ Boehlje asked Barron’s, ‘when you can buy an S&P index stock for something no higher than 20?’

Farmland selling at a 77% valuation premium to its 50-year average seems hard to justify. But this data is only for Central Indiana.

What about Iowa?

By my back of the envelope calculations using data from Iowa State University’s website Ag Decision Maker, multiples in Iowa seem similarly elevated. Comparing the estimated statewide average value for “Medium Quality Farmland” of $8,076 an acre (September 2014) with their statewide average of $260 an acre cash rent (May 2014) gives a multiple of about 31.

No matter how you slice it, this seems expensive to me given rising production costs and low commodity prices.

Still, holding is fine if you are a farmer and your balance sheet lacks debt so you can handle a downturn, as your holding period may approximate forever.

Investors Beware

But, absent a substantial and rapid bounceback in commodities prices that could drive further cash rent growth I have a hard time seeing how you make farmland work as an investment from current price levels.

I see little reason to be a buyer of farmland here given fundamentals, valuation, and the potential for higher interest rates. And unless your time horizon is nearly infinite, it seems likely to be a good time to consider lightening up.

See also:
September 2014 Iowa Land Trends and Values Survey

Average farmland rental rates decline modestly for 2014

Less than 1% of Daytraders Are Consistent Winners!

12 Friday Sep 2014

Posted by JC in Uncategorized

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

Investing, Trading

This shocking result comes from the TraderFeed blog of Dr. Brett Steenbarger, who is a well-known trading coach and psychologist. He references a study by Barber, Lee, Liu, and Odean.

Coming from Dr. Steenbarger, these findings are hard to dismiss as the ravings of someone with an ax to grind against trading.

From the study:

In the average year, 360,000 individuals engage in day trading. While about 13% earn profits net of fees in the typical year, the results of our analysis suggest that less than 1% of day traders (less than 1,000 out of 360,000) are able to outperform consistently.

Trading Is Not For Me

Disclaimer: I studied technical analysis and trading several years ago and decided that I had neither the skill nor the temperament for it. It also seemed to me like a zero-sum game that had a winner-take-all dynamic about it, with a bunch of people donating their capital or slogging along near breakeven to finance a few big winners.

I had informally figured 5% to 10% of traders made real money, so it shocked even me that the figure is less than 1%.

Maybe you figure you will be part of the lucky 0.28%. Good luck, but the upset stomach and 24/7 nature of the endeavor wouldn’t be worth it for me even if the odds of success were 50/50.

Don’t Trade, Invest

I suggest instead a lengthened time horizon and thinking like a partner in a business. Focus on intrinsic value and buying with a margin of safety.

I also suggest dropping everything to read Risk Revisited, the latest memo from Howard Marks. It is a master tour of the world of risk from one of the world’s great investors.

Associate With the Right People

And since humans are doomed to mimicry, you should follow Jason Zweig’s advice:

So try to socialize — in the real world and in online social media — only with investors who are calm and methodical. After all, whatever your peers pay attention to, you will also concentrate on — so following more-sensible people will help inoculate you against panic.

Other Links of Interest:
Video: Howard Marks on Risk Assessment, Market Strategy

Why you shouldn’t watch the market intra-day

The Stock Market’s Missing Ingredient

Even Warren Buffett Gets Killed In the Stock Market

An Important Dividend Cut Case Study

Video: Eric Falkenstein Interview on the Flawed Academic Notion of Risk

René Girard and Mimetic Desire: Imitation and Envy Are the Keys to Human Behavior

31 Sunday Aug 2014

Posted by JC in Uncategorized

≈ 2 Comments

Tags

Envy, Human Behavior, Investing

René Girard is one of the great intellectuals of the 20th Century. He can perhaps best be called a theoretical anthropologist, but he is a true multi-disciplinary thinker. In addition to anthropology, his work crosses into such fields as literary criticism, philosophy, theology, sociology, and psychology.

His many books include Violence and the Sacred, The Scapegoat, Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World, and Battling to the End. In my search for understanding, I feel privileged to have encountered his genius.

He sees myth and anthropology as one and the same, and both as vital to understanding humanity.

Mimetic Desire

Girard’s concept of Mimetic Desire is a revelation that explains humanity on both a micro and a macro level. His basic insight is that imitation, and in particular imitated desire, is the foundation of human relationships.

One person desires an object and designates it to another as desirable. The imitated individual is confirmed as correct in his desire when he sees the other also moving toward the same object.

Whether food, water, or a desirable mate, truly desirable objects are always limited in number. This causes conflict as multiple individuals move toward the same scarce objects.

The Scapegoat and Archaic Religion

This natural state of conflict should have prevented humans from gathering in permanent groups, save the scapegoat mechanism.

The scapegoat allowed the group to unite against a victim and quelled conflict within the group. In allowing the group to unite and society to form, the victim was god-like in allowing humanity to progress.

Girard thus sees scapegoating, as codified by ritual sacrifice in archaic religions, as being critical to the evolution of human society.

He sees evidence of this in the fact that there is a universal foundational myth of the periodic sacrifice of a sacred king who dies and is resurrected.

Girard and the Christian Deviation

Girard sees Christianity as a sea change for humanity. For the first time it is revealed that the victim is innocent.

Whether or not you are a Christian, it is fascinating to consider the story of Christ in light of Mimetic Theory and the universal foundational myth.

Girard sees Christianity as potentially destroying the power of scapegoating and the archaic sacred to solve problems by revealing the truth about its foundational lie, that the victim was innocent.

In this way, Christianity paved the way for rational, scientific inquiry to explain the world. In Girard’s formulation, we didn’t stop burning witches because we invented science, we invented science because we stopped burning witches.

History is a Test that Humanity is Failing

As the superstitions of the old order no longer restrain human behavior, humanity increasingly also rejects Christianity’s message of peace and refusal of violence.  Human destructive potential has grown as we have lost our moral bearings.

Girard sees these as truly apocalyptic times as our capacity to destroy each other and our world seemingly dwarfs our inclination to move beyond the old, primitive order of envy, conflict, and the search for scapegoats.

My Conclusions

So Girard sees imitation of behavior as key to understanding humans and humanity. Not just imitation of desire, but imitation of conflict, imitation of rivalry, and other behaviors. This goes a long way toward explaining herding and boom/bust cycles in markets.

Imitated desire plus scarcity means envy is key to understanding human behavior. Envy better describes human nature than greed.

Imitation and envy together explain rivalry between friends and peers as well as sports, capitalism, and war.

Imitation, scarcity, envy, and scapegoating are powerful and omnipresent factors in human behavior, many times subconscious. There are many profound lessons here for politics, business, investing, and life.

Looking at things through a Girardian lens has altered my understanding of myself and the world.

“It’s not greed that drives the world, but envy.” — Warren Buffett

Also see:

Insights with René Girard

Bishop Barron on René Girard

Rene Girard | The Scapegoat | Complete 5-part CBC ‘Ideas’ series with David Cayley (2001)

Michael Mauboussin: Investment Wisdom

05 Tuesday Aug 2014

Posted by JC in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Investing

This interview of Michael Mauboussin by Barry Ritholtz is just fantastic. If you really want to understand how to think about investing, you couldn’t have a better guide. The interaction between Michael and Barry is very revealing and a must listen.

https://soundcloud.com/bloombergview/barry-ritholtz-interviews-mauboussin-masters-in-business

Along the same lines, both men are big fans of Charlie Munger. Here is a link to several Munger gems:

Special Treat: All Things Charlie Munger

← Older posts
Newer posts →

Recent Posts

  • Climate Lunacy Continues Despite Inconvenient Truths
  • Reason in the Internet Age: How you can avoid getting stampeded into poor conclusions and buying into silly conspiracy theories
  • Climate Change is a Real Problem, but Current Renewable Energy Technologies Can’t Replace Fossil Fuels Without a Huge Nuclear Buildout. Because, Physics.
  • Larry Fink’s Convoluted & Coercive Solution to the Problems of Indexing
  • The Wisdom of Charlie Munger: You Have a Moral Duty To Be Rational and Reasonable, and To Eliminate Your Own Ignorance

Archives

  • October 2021
  • November 2020
  • August 2019
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • January 2017
  • July 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • August 2015
  • June 2015
  • April 2015
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • July 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • April 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013
  • October 2013

Categories

  • Uncategorized

Meta

  • Create account
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Subscribe Subscribed
    • Zone of Competence
    • Join 28 other subscribers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Zone of Competence
    • Subscribe Subscribed
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...